My mother is losing her hearing.
It drives me crazy because she won’t admit she can’t hear me and yet the other day was talking about us going on a trip together. At that point, I pretended I couldn’t hear because of what happened the last time we traveled together.
In 2001, we went to Italy for 9 days to celebrate my mother’s 70th birthday. In the months prior to our departure, according to my mother, she had become quite the athlete. She’d brag about how much she’d walked, the weights she’d lifted, how she’d hired a trainer. She was also working full time during that period and in my mind sounded just like your average 40 year old.
Anyway, on the day of our departure, I knew something was up, when, as I was waiting outside the Delta terminal at JFK and my father pulled up to the curb, I couldn’t help but notice that in the time it took for him to get out of the car, open the trunk, pull out the luggage, walk it over and put it down next to me, my mother, the urban Olympiad, still hadn’t fully pulled herself out of the passenger seat.
We spent our first four days in Rome. Everywhere we went my mother insisted we walk. I had no problem with it except we’d sign up for tours and end up arriving late to every one of them because, no matter how early we left, Flo Jo, just couldn’t seem to pick up the pace.
My mother’s hearing problem turned out to be the only self- diagnosed disease she’s ever actually suffered from. Please don’t think me insensitive when I say I could have killed the mute but as the days ticked by it got harder and harder to hang onto to my patience when every conversation between us sounded like this.
JESSICA: Ma, do you want to get tickets to see the statue of David?
MY MOTHER: Okay, but I’m not really very hungry.
The one time my mother seemed to fulfill the image she’d painted of herself as a true athlete, was when we were shopping. Inside every store, she would speed walk from rack to rack, her ears so clear, she could hear a hanger drop in a haystack. This woman who couldn’t add two and two together on a calculator was suddenly able to figure out the vat tax on every item and the cost in U.S. dollars.
After Rome we headed to Florence. As we rode through the countryside my mother fell fast asleep. I couldn’t help but watch her. I felt so so sad and afraid all of a sudden because, trust me, when a person my mother’s age falls asleep, mouth open, head back, I can’t help but build an imaginary wooden box around her and picture her as “gone to a better place”.
After Florence, we headed for Venice, where my role as caregiver to the elderly and people who lie about their physical abilities, continued. That was until “it” happened. “It” being 9/11.
My mother and I had now been together for eight days. At that point, we were like two strangers who’d been thrown together by circumstance rather then choice and the only thing we could really agree on by then was how much we hated the pigeons. Being true New Yorkers and Jews, my mother and I couldn’t look at a pigeon without thinking, “exterminator.” Time after time, as we walked through San Marco Square, we’d flail our arms and yell to the birds, “uchh, get, get out of here, go” while all these other people with birdseed on their heads and arms, standing perfectly still while the pigeons ate off them, would look at my mother and I like we were the crazy ones.
The day of our scheduled departure we went to the airport, even though we had no idea whether or not our plane would take off. After a lot of pleading and cajoling, a ticket agent found a flight from Milan to Toronto to New York. The problem was there was only one seat.
Lying through my teeth, I told my mother:
JESSICA: Go, I’ll be fine.
even though I was really thinking:
JESSICA’S THOUGHT: If you leave me here alone, I’m going to flip out. In no way am I remotely sincere when I say it’s okay to leave so for the love of God, do NOT take me up on my offer.
Happily, I didn’t need to say anything. As it turned out, my pain in the ass, quasi-deaf, delusional about her capabilities mother, turned out to also be a mind reader and a fighter. With a look of determination on her face, she said to me,
MY MOTHER: We’re leaving here together or we’re not going.
Ten minutes later, thanks to my mother, I was headed for my flight from Milan to Los Angeles with a stopover in Montreal.
It’s been several years since that time and her hearing is worse. Any conversation between us sounds more like an argument. She still shops. She has a band of friends who could listen to her talk forever and they do and she does.
The difference now is I’m a mother and if there’s one thing this whole experience taught me, it’s that if I were Phoebe, I don’t think I could spend nine days with me anywhere.



